Is it cheaper to buy an iPhone outright with a SIM-only plan?


WhistleOut
21 April 2016

Whether it is cheaper to buy a phone outright or on a plan is a question we are asked a lot. There used to be a strong argument in favour of an outright purchase a few years ago. But as our favourite phones become more expensive, the savings seemed to have dwindled or disappeared.

Is this true for the iPhone 6s and 6s Plus? Is it better to grab one through at an Apple store and choose a cheap SIM Only plan? Or, are the telcos battling for your business with unbeatable handset pricing?

There’s only one way to find out. Bust out the calculators!

To make fair comparisons, we’ll include:

  • iPhone 6s 64GB & iPhone 6s Plus 64GB
  • Plans with unlimited calls and SMS
  • 3GB data or more

Full the comparison, we'll list a phone price and plan price separately. For the telcos, the phone price is the monthly handset repayment multiplied by 24 months.

Telco

iPhone 6s 64GB handset cost

iPhone 6s Plus 64GB handset cost

Plan cost per month and incl. data

Min total cost over 24 months
(iPhone 6s)

Min total cost over 24 months
(iPhone 6s Plus)

Telstra

$624

$768

$3695
(6GB)

$2832

$3048

See the plans

Optus

$552

$840

$60
(3GB)

$2064

$2280

See the plans

Vodafone

$552

$936

$60
(3GB)

$2064

$2376

See the plans

Virgin Mobile

$624

$912

$60
(4GB)

$1992

$2352

See the plans

Amaysim

$1229

$1379

$39.90
(5GB)

$2186

$2456

See the plans

AlDI Mobile

$1229

$1379

$45
(4.5GB)

$2309

$2459

See the plans

TPG

$1229

$1379

$39.99
(5GB)

$2198

$2348

See the plans

Boost Mobile

$1229

$1379

$40
(3GB)

$2189

$2339

See the plans

Jeenee Mobile

$1229

$1379

$35
(3GB)

$2069

$2219

See the plans

As you can see above, for most of the plans in this comparison there is $100 or more to save by choosing a telco plan over an outright purchase and a SIM Only plan. The difference between the two options is least when the SIM Only plan costs $40 per month — which gives you a good indication of how much of the phone cost is built into the telco plans.

Let’s add in a few more SIM Only plans for consideration, but this time we’ll bend the rules and show lower prices. These plans all have at least 500 calling minutes and 1.5GB data.

Telco

iPhone 6s 64GB handset cost

iPhone 6s Plus 64GB handset cost

Plan cost per month

Min total cost over 24 months
(iPhone 6s)

Min total cost over 24 months
(iPhone 6s Plus)

Telstra

$792

$1104

$70
(2.5GB)

$2472

$2784

See the plans

Optus

$552

$840

$60
(3GB)

$2064

$2280

See the plans

Vodafone

$552

$936

$60
(3GB)

$2064

$2376

See the plans

Virgin Mobile

$720

$960

$50
(2GB)

$1920

$2160

See the plans

Amaysim

$1229

$1379

$24.90
(1.5GB)

$1826

$1976

See the plans

Vaya

$1229

$1379

$20
(1.5GB)

$1709

$1859

See the plans

Think Mobile

$1229

$1379

$32.95
(2GB)

$2019

$2169

See the plans

Spintel

$1229

$1379

$27 
(2GB)

$1877

$2027

See the plans

If you’re prepared to choose a lower-cost, lower-value SIM Only plan, the maths leans in favour of an outright purchase. Vaya plans meet the criteria and are very cheap over the 24 months. Amaysim and Spintel both have great plans under $30, and you'll save about $160 over the comparable plans from Optus and Virgin.

But, you'll miss out on a bunch of great plan benefits too. Both Optus and Virgin include international calls in plans, Virgin has Data Rollover and Optus plans can be combined into a Data Pool. Vodafone has similar features, plus its popular $5 international roaming for travellers.

The savings are there for low-to-medium data users, but does the cost difference offset the absence of great plan benefits? Is the freedom to switch carriers and plans with SIM Only plans worth more than all the savings added up? That'll be up to you to decide.

One thing is certain, the days when there was a considerable difference in price are long gone -- especially with an expensive phone model like the iPhone 6s.

Feature Image:
Yeamake / Shutterstock.com


Comments

WhistleOut

Australia's Leading Site For Comparing Mobile Phones & Plans

We unpack 8,081 complex mobile phone plan combinations from 29 carriers so you can find a new plan in seconds.

Start Comparing


  • Optus
  • Telstra
  • Vodafone
  • Virgin Mobile
  • Amaysim
  • Boost Mobile
  • Vaya
  • Woolworths


Compare phones and plans from the following carriers...

Personal

Business

Featured Deals

Want 11GB data + $100 Cash Back for $50/month?

This $50 SIM plan has no lock-in contract, bonus data, unlimited standard national calls & texts + $300 for International calling

50% off online SIM purchases

Grab a Lebara Prepaid SIM; now with more included data, international calling on selected plans plus 50% off your first recharge.

Pennywise SIM Bonuses from Jeenee Mobile

Free set-up on all Unlimited Pennywise plans plus unlimited calls & SMS within Australia and get 2GB bonus data with $35 Pennywise Unlimited

50% off for 3 Months

BYO Phone or Tablet to OVO and get stacks of data, unlimited calling & OVOPlay sporting action delivered direct to your device....all for 50% less for the first 3 months